Located just steps away from some of New York’s most iconic destinations, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer at 45 West 35th Street has quickly become a must-visit spot for anyone seeking delicious, bold flavors in the heart of the city. Nestled between 5th and 6th Avenues, this Herald Square location combines award-winning burgers, towering milkshakes, and a lively atmosphere that will leave you wanting more.

Whether you’re a tourist exploring the nearby Empire State Building or Madison Square Garden, or a local looking for your next favorite dining spot, Black Tap delivers an unforgettable dining experience for everyone. With its mix of retro vibes, street art decor, and a soundtrack filled with classic hip-hop, Black Tap isn't just about the food—it's an all-around sensory experience​.

Why Black Tap Stands Out

Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer has built its reputation on creating some of the most inventive and mouthwatering burgers in New York City. But what really makes it stand out from other burger joints near Herald Square is its ability to offer both quality and creativity, making it a standout option for food near Herald Square NYC.

As soon as you step into Black Tap, you're greeted with a warm and bustling environment. The team behind Black Tap is all about keeping the burger scene fresh and exciting. Their chefs use high-quality ingredients, and their secret to crafting the perfect burger lies in their unique preparation process—griddling the burgers rather than grilling them, ensuring they’re juicy and flavorful​. Add to that a soft potato roll and a range of decadent toppings, and you have a burger experience like no other.

The Best Craft Burgers in Herald Square

Black Tap’s menu is packed with options for everyone, and the craft burgers are the star of the show. With choices that range from simple classics to bold, flavor-packed creations, every bite offers something new and exciting.

For a timeless option, try the All-American Burger, which is a nod to classic flavors with a fresh twist. It features prime beef, American cheese, and Black Tap’s special sauce, all served on a soft potato roll​. But if you're after something more daring, the Greg Norman Burger is an absolute must-try. This award-winning burger comes with a half-pound Wagyu beef patty, blue cheese, and arugula, and it has won the People’s Choice Award multiple times at the NYC Wine & Food Festival’s Burger Bash​.

Other crowd-pleasers include the Texan Burger, topped with crispy onion rings, Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce, and bacon, and the Mexico City Burger, which brings a spicy kick with pickled jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, and chipotle mayo​. Every burger is served with fries, lettuce, tomato, and a pickle, and you can customize your meal with add-ons like avocado, fried egg, or house-made sauces.

CrazyShakes®: A New York Favorite

While the burgers may be the main attraction, Black Tap’s CrazyShakes® are what take the dining experience to a whole new level. These milkshakes are so over-the-top that they’ve become a destination on their own. You’ve probably seen them on Instagram—tall, towering creations piled high with candy, cookies, and even slices of cake​.

Some of the most popular options include the Cotton Candy Shake, which comes topped with actual cotton candy and colorful candies, and the Sweet N’ Salty, a peanut butter shake adorned with chocolate pretzels, peanut butter cups, and M&Ms​. These shakes are as much a feast for the eyes as they are for the taste buds, and they’ve helped solidify Black Tap’s status as a must-visit for food lovers in NYC.

Beyond Burgers and Shakes: More to Enjoy

While Black Tap is famous for its burgers and shakes, its menu extends beyond those iconic dishes. Their selection of sides and snacks is impressive, offering everything from Fried Pickles and Buttermilk Fried Chicken Tenders to Crispy Brussels Sprouts and Teriyaki Broccoli​. These make perfect appetizers or sharable plates if you're dining with friends.

For those looking for something lighter, Black Tap also offers fresh salads, including the Burger Chopped Salad, which brings all the flavor of a burger in a healthier form. Another popular choice is the Falafel Burger Salad, a vegan-friendly option loaded with hummus, tahini, and vegan feta​.

Craft Beers and Cocktails

Black Tap also takes its drinks seriously, offering an impressive lineup of craft beers, cocktails, and wines. Whether you’re craving a local brew or a creative cocktail, there’s something on the menu to complement your meal​. The rotating selection of beers often includes collaborations with local breweries, giving you the chance to try something new each time you visit.

If cocktails are more your style, don’t miss the CheerWine Old Fashioned or the Smoky Manhattan, both of which put a creative twist on classic drinks​.

Perfect for Locals and Tourists Alike

One of the best things about Black Tap is its location. Situated right near Herald Square, it’s an ideal spot for both locals and tourists. Whether you're shopping at Macy’s, catching a show at Madison Square Garden, or commuting through Penn Station, Black Tap is the perfect place to stop and refuel​. The restaurant’s proximity to some of the city’s top attractions makes it a convenient choice for those exploring Midtown Manhattan.

The casual, upbeat atmosphere is perfect for a quick lunch with friends, a family outing, or even an after-work meet-up. With its welcoming vibe and diverse menu, Black Tap caters to all types of diners.

Easy Takeout and Delivery Options

If you're pressed for time or just want to enjoy Black Tap’s burgers from the comfort of your home, the restaurant offers easy takeout and delivery options. You can order directly from their website or through popular delivery apps, ensuring you never miss out on one of New York’s best burger experiences​.

Plan Your Visit

If you're on the hunt for the best food near Herald Square NYC, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer should be at the top of your list. Whether you're craving a classic burger, one of their award-winning creations, or a CrazyShake® that’s perfect for sharing, Black Tap offers an experience that is second to none. Located in the heart of Midtown, it’s a dining destination that combines flavor, creativity, and fun in every meal.

So next time you're near Herald Square, be sure to stop by Black Tap and see for yourself why this burger joint is one of the city’s top spots for both locals and visitors alike.